On imagining other lives and noticing the one we’re in.

These days when I go somewhere, I wonder who I would be if I stayed. Not the grocery store. A place where people live.
In October we went to Madeline Island, and I wondered.
I read a sign that explained the 14-mile-by-3-mile island on Lake Superior was the prophesied end-point of a journey that ancestors of the Anishinaabe began at the St. Lawrence River more than a thousand years ago. My husband was born by the St. Lawrence River a comparatively measly four-and-a-half decades ago, but the area is far away from where we live now, and I’ve never been. Madeline Island, where I’d also never been until recently, is where a whole people came to live. The sign said it was their promised land.
Twenty-odd years ago, I read Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance. There’s a line in the book: “The only Zen you find on the tops of mountains is the Zen you bring up there.” I used to think it was true. I felt inspired to work on myself because I knew that going to the tops of mountains wouldn’t let me escape my true nature. When I watched what my mind did, it seemed accurate. Wherever I went, sure enough, there I was.
But then I watched my mind a little more, and the idea seemed not quite as true. Or at least it required an asterisk. When I walked into a room where I didn’t know anyone, I was a shy person. When I hiked by myself in the dessert, I was a strong person. When I stood in front of big water, I was a calm and sometimes scared person. It began to seem obvious that the me at the top of a mountain might be different from the me down low. Wherever I went, there I was, perhaps, but what I did and how I felt weren’t the same.
Who would I be if I lived on Madeline Island?
I might be a less rushed and more resourceful person. Amazon will deliver fabric markers to my house in St. Paul in three hours if I order now. When I change the address to the cabin where we stayed on Madeline Island, Amazon didn’t seem to want to deliver them at all but could get them to the town hall on the island in about one hundred and twenty hours. Reasonable, but a good deal longer. Maybe if I lived on Madeline Island I would decide that I don’t need fabric markers after all.
I might also be a lonelier person. A painter we met there said about 500 people live year-round on Madeline Island now, about twice what it was before the pandemic. You can double your social world when you take a boat or ferry to Bayfield just across the lake on the Wisconsin mainland, which has about 584 people according to the 2020 Census. In the winter, though, a personal boat isn’t a good idea, and even the ferry won’t run once the ice builds up enough. Then you take a windsled or wait for the ice to be 11 inches thick so you can drive your car across. I was at a bookstore in Bayfield one year the day the ice road opened. A woman burst in, having just made the trip. She said it had been months since she’d seen her friend the bookseller. Maybe the woman who burst in hadn’t been a lonely person, but I think I would be.
It’s easier to imagine how a place might affect you than to realize how a place is already affecting you.
Who am I because of where I live?
That’s a big question. In my research methods classes in college and grad school, we learned that if you want to be able to arrive at useful conclusions, you need to ask the right questions. Specificity is key.
Who am I because I live in St. Paul? Not specific enough.
Who am I because I live in my house? Now we’re getting somewhere.
I’ve lived in the same house for almost six years now. But, if I’m honest, I haven’t really lived in the same place. I don’t live in a whole city or even a whole house. I live in the spaces I inhabit within those spaces. During some periods, I mostly lived at my desk. Then I was a stressed person. During others, I made a nest on our couch and was a recovering person.
Within the same room, I can even carve out a different place. When I chop vegetables at the kitchen counter, I’m a creative person. When I sip tea with a friend at the kitchen island, I’m a social person.
It’s hard to know the me I’d be if I lived on a mountaintop or on Madeline Island. I’ll probably never know. But when I ask a smaller question, I can test it right now. Who am I when I spend my time here? Is it who I want to be?
What about now?
And now?

New Article From Me

Bipolar Research & Insights: Injectable Antipsychotics, Ketamine, Sleep, and More | October 2026
When you live with a chronic health condition like bipolar disorder, the usual concept of resilience as “bouncing back” doesn’t quite fit. But people with bipolar disorder show profound resilience all the time. A new study asked adults with the condition what resilience looks like for them and what helps. I cover this study and four others on ketamine, injectable medications, sleep, and blood pressure in my October research column for bpHope.
Book Recommendation

Helen of Nowhere, by Makenna Goodman
When I don’t know what to read next, sometimes I’ll peruse The Booker Prize’s list of year’s past for ideas. I find it to be a reliable, often library-available (if sometimes overly erudite) assortment.
This year the emeritus Macalester College professor Marlon James’s latest book, The Disappearers, has been shortlisted (and received an absolutely incandescent New York Times Book Review). As the founder and director of a book club for Macalester alumni, I felt it was my duty to read it. And I will, I swear. But at 613 pages and heavy with James’s characteristic smarter-than-me prose, it’s a bit of a doorstopper. While it’s sure to be a literary feast, I decided I needed a Booker amuse-bouche to ready myself. So, when I spotted the narrow spine of the 2026-Booker-Longlisted Helen of Nowhere on a shelf at Apostle Islands Booksellers, I snapped it up. I finished it within a 24-hour period over MEA Weekend, Minnesota’s version of fall break. (Another fun Minnesota fact: Minneapolis-based Coffee House Press published the book!)
The back cover says Helen of Nowhere is a philosophical book, and I think that’s right. It’s about a professor who, after decades of being celebrated, finds the world around him not quite so appreciative anymore. Now his career and marriage are over. He comes to a for-sale house in the unspoiled wilderness, hoping it has what he needs. The story is both of this world and not. I was happy to be wherever it was for 141 pages. Now, I need to talk about it. Maybe with you?
Apostle Islands Booksellers | Amazon | Bookshop
Browse more books on my Bookshop | Read more reviews on my Goodreads
Thanks for reading! You can make sure you never miss an original essay, new article, or book recommendation if you sign up for my monthly newsletter. Enter your email now to stay connected.
** I get commissions for purchases made through links in this post.
As always your newsletters bring me so much comfort, joy and this one in particular a great deal of perspective into thinking more about who I am in the spaces I inhabit….thank you for all you bring to my world whether in these newsletters, random passing-bys and our walks together ❤️
Heather